Product– Dungeon Crawl Classics #109: Beneath the Isle of Serpents

System– DCC RPG

Producer– Goodman Games

Price–  $7.99 here https://www.drivethrurpg.com//product/539156/dungeon-crawl-classics-109-beneath-the-isle-of-serpents?affiliate_id=658618  

TL; DR– A solid picture of an adventure but the framing is muddy.  93%

Basics- Time to stop a war!  Beneath the Isle of Serpents features a mysterious island off the coast where people disappear, and fights not only among the humans lead to horrors no one expected.  This is an adventure for 2nd-level characters.

Mechanics or Crunch: This has classic Goodman Game polish for the crunch.  It’s low crunch but fun with fights, social encounters, tables galore, and exploration across both dungeons and a mysterious island.  The math is solid and fun.  5/5

Theme or Fluff– When we are on the island, stuff works, but getting there is a bit harder.  The hooks of a war don’t really matter.  Also, there is a bit of stuff happening between the intelligent monsters.  Those things I feel are not as well developed.  But the other parts and random things in the dungeon are all fun.  The pieces on this island are fun, but the framing doesn’t quite line up.  4.5/5

Execution: This adventure has all the awesome parts of a classic Goodman Games adventure, but it also has the faults of one.  Goodman Games harkens back to the old school adventures of ol’.  But modern audiences might not like that layout and setup.  I do, and I want more.  But I respect the opinion that the layout is not user-friendly.   4.5/5

Summary: This is another solid Goodman Games adventure.  The crunch is solid with fun fights, good social, and tables of such random materials that it’s a crazy fun time.  The story in the crawl is fun, but getting there is a bit off.  Not horrible, but a bit hard to fit into a perfect story.  The execution is good, but it’s Goodman Games OGL style.  If you love that, you will love this.  I think this is a fun side crawl in The Caverns of Thracia campaign.  93%

Product– Dungeon Crawl Classics #110: The Sacrificial Pyre of Thracia 

System– DCC RPG

Producer– Goodman Games

Price–  $5.99 here  https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/539158/dungeon-crawl-classics-110-the-sacrificial-pyre-of-thracia?affiliate_id=658618 

TL; DR– Either add more or remove to help with this one. 93%

Basics- Where are they!?  Cultists are attacking your lands.  Find where they are, make friends along the way, and route them out from their caves!

Mechanics or Crunch: Standard fun for DCC in this one.  Lots of low-level enemies to fight and kill.  There is a bit of socializing, a bit of exploration, and lots of combat.  All as balanced as random can be!  5/5

Theme or Fluff– I love the pieces, but I either want more or less of them.  This adventure has a hex crawl.  This goes without saying-THERE IS NOT ENOUGH HEX CRAWLS IN THE WORLD!  But the hexes are kind of empty.  There are random encounters, but I’d like more storytelling with finding specific things along the way. Give me more staged stuff to do.  You wonder and find things, but you don’t get much of a story till you find a village.  Events and findings outside the village will help a bit.  This might also save on the other problem of the adventure-time.  Hex crawls with random encounters are either the most amazing thing ever, a snooze, or a slog.  It’s random, so you don’t get the sweet spot of the number of encounters the creators hoped for often.  I’d either add more to the hexes or just cut that and have a combat and a social outside the volcano to save time.  The volcano lair is fine.  Nothing beats a fight with bad guys in a dead volcano.  4.5/5

Execution:  This is DCC.  It’s got the best part of old school, but it’s got a few warts of old school with the layout.  If you know how to read these, then it’s completely fine.  If you are new, this might be a bit harder.  Not bad, but less clean than your WotC-produced adventures.  But I go to tons of less pretty places with amazing menus, so for a bit of atmosphere and disarray, you will be fine here.  4.5/5

Summary: This is a solid, fun adventure that randomness can completely mess up.  I love a good strange hex crawl, but those hex crawls can be a pain if the dice roll weird.  I’d like a bit more story in some hexes to really amp up the overall story, but what’s here is solid enough. Good fun for you and your friends as they enter Thracia! 93%

Product– DCC Day #3: Chanters in the Dark

System– DCC RPG

Producer– Goodman Games

Price–  $6.00 here https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/395901/dcc-day-3-chanters-in-the-dark?affiliate_id=658618 

TL; DR– Good DCC up till the end. 90%

Basics- Who calls from below?!  Chanters in the Dark is a one-shot adventure where the characters are drawn into a world of intrigue and subterranean threats.  Will they be able to save everyone, or will the things from below eat them all?

Mechanics or Crunch: This adventure covers a lot of places, but fumbles a bit at the end.  The bulk of the adventure is urban, as the players meet new people, possibly kill them, and then have to escape.  The escape is the least fun.  Basically, the characters have to run away.  It’s not as exciting as a final fight, but it does make thematic sense. 4.5/5

Theme or Fluff– This is a good mix of exploration, combat, and skills, but the end is less fun.  The town the players explore and the religion they may attack are both fleshed out.  It’s a very meaty adventure for a book this size.  The one issue is the end, as the players just run.  Nothing else, but climb quickly.  That diminishes the other parts.  Not enough to not make it fun, but I saw some players lose some interest.  4.5/5

Execution: DCC polarizes some with its layout, and here it’s a bit less troubling but still old-school.  There are multiple pages of two columns.  It reads more easily than the real old-school, but if you are annoyed by the basic layout, this will not win you over.  I would like more art, but what’s here is solid.  4.5/5

Summary– This is a good adventure that fumbles in the last minutes.  The bulk is lots of fun , but I’d like the end to be a bit more active than a few rolls.  It works as a story, but a bit more would be fun.  That said, I enjoyed it and suggest everyone check this one out.  90%