TL; DR– A fun place to play, but pack your own story. 93%
Basics: Are you worthy of the flame? The Isle of Sin is a location adventure where the players are caught up in a cult’s antics. What will you do when you meet the Burned man?
Mechanics or Crunch: This has solid mechanics. The monsters are a good fit, and the problems the players face fit well within Pirate Borg’s crunch. 5/5
Theme or Fluff– I like what’s here, but I’m just not sure why I’m here. The Isle of Sin is fun with phobias, random charts, and well-crafted enemies. But this really isn’t a one-shot adventure- it’s a one-shot location. I need a bit more story to guide my players and me. 4/5
Execution: Pirate Borg has a solid community, and this work is on par with the best. It has a good layout, nice art, and clear guidance that makes it easy for players to navigate. The price and craftsmanship are exactly what I expect for this one. 5/5
Summary: Pirate Borg has amazing settings. This book is no different. The only bad part is that this isn’t really an adventure. I need a bit more story direction. The book description has a more direct story than the book itself does. If you have a good story, then this is an awesome place to play. If you don’t, then maybe check other adventures. 93%
Concentration Mental Monk Prerequisites Drunken Boxing Requirements You are in Drunken Stance. Area 30-foot emanation Defense Will; Duration 1 minute
You start dancing, and your drunken antics distract your foes. Enemies in the area must succeed at a Will save or gain the Distracted 1 condition as long as they can see you and you continue dancing. Each turn you continue to dance, you gain a +1 circumstance bonus to AC and reflex saves.
Basics: We want a crew. Why wouldn’t you join? The Repentant is a ship-based adventure where the players join as crew, but the crew might need them for more than just workers.
Mechanics or Crunch: This book expands the game’s mechanics in fun ways. The book is full of monsters, shanties, items, and other goodies. The stuff here is well done and a fun addition to Pirate Borg. 5/5
Theme or Fluff– This is a great place to play, but not so much an adventure. The book has solid hooks, but the onus of the adventure is on the players. The players have to take the reins to really make stuff happen. I love all the pieces the author made, but there isn’t a set story beyond how the players play in this sandbox. 4.25/5
Execution: I’m seeing a solid trend in Pirate Borg. The author releases art and picture packages with their PDF. I love this. The style may clutter the substance a bit, but it’s like the 80’s metal album covers obscured the song titles. I’m ok with this, and it really sells the whole package. 5/5
Summary: This is a solid place to start a campaign. You’ve got new toys for the Pirate Borg toolbox. You’ve got fun things to fight, and you’ve got a whole ship to play with after the adventure. I got the hooks I wanted for this adventure, but I’d like a bit more guidance on how to run this or some direct story to follow. But if the main complaint is that I need more handholding, this is a good place to learn storytelling on my own. 95%
Thou seekest the future from god. Roll three d20s. Thou take d4 damage. You can substitute any three dice rolls for the next of your dice rolls at any time, in order. Any person you can see must accept your dice roll over their own.