Ring Side Report: RPG Review of The Battle of Dead Man’s Cove

Product– The Battle of Dead Man’s Cove

System– Pirate Borg

Producer– Limithron

Price– $2.99 here: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/443422/the-battle-of-dead-man-s-cove?affiliate_id=658618

TL; DR– Two hours, in and out ship intro!  100%

Basics: Where is Captain Red Wolf!?  This is a quick, play to learn game of Pirate Borg.  You pirate a ship, fight a bad guy, and then kill an evil spirit.  DONE!

Mechanics or Crunch:  This adventure is just to teach mechanics.  It’s a bit easier, but still fun. You have three ships vs. one and a monster if the GM wants.  Then it’s a fight in a cave with skeletons.  Solid, easy-to-learn mechanics adventure.  5/5

Theme or Fluff– The goal here isn’t to rewrite the Odyssey.  You kill a bad guy, then kill him in a cave.  It’s got enough to give you crazy stuff to play with along the way, so its not just a roll-off.  So, its a fun learning scenario.    5/5

Execution: The one thing you need to make this better legally can’t be included.  This is part of Limithron.  It’s good stuff, but it’s not officially Free League.  It’s allowed to publish under that banner.  So, the best things that will help are the Pirate Borg handouts in the basic box.  That said, it’s still done well.  It’s short, but it has maps to use.  It has a good layout, with extra bits to keep the story alive and fun pieces for players to grab onto.   5/5

Summary: This is a good con or drop-in scenario.  If you just want an hour of fun, you can do the ship combat.  If you want more, you can do the cave and skeletons.  The main thing to keep in mind is that this is a teaching adventure.  You will not rewrite all of English literature with this adventure, but you will get the best cannon and swashbuckling intro you can for this price. 100%

Ring Side Report: RPG Review of The Isle of Sin

Product– The Isle of Sin

System– Pirate Borg

Producer– Dragon Peak Publishing

Price– $2.99 here: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/489303/the-isle-of-sin-pirate-borg?affiliate_id=658618

TL; DR– A fun place to play, but pack your own story.  93%

Basics: Are you worthy of the flame?  The Isle of Sin is a location adventure where the players are caught up in a cult’s antics.  What will you do when you meet the Burned man?

Mechanics or Crunch:  This has solid mechanics.  The monsters are a good fit, and the problems the players face fit well within Pirate Borg’s crunch.  5/5

Theme or Fluff– I like what’s here, but I’m just not sure why I’m here.  The Isle of Sin is fun with phobias, random charts, and well-crafted enemies.  But this really isn’t a one-shot adventure- it’s a one-shot location.  I need a bit more story to guide my players and me.    4/5

Execution: Pirate Borg has a solid community, and this work is on par with the best.  It has a good layout, nice art, and clear guidance that makes it easy for players to navigate.  The price and craftsmanship are exactly what I expect for this one.  5/5

Summary: Pirate Borg has amazing settings.  This book is no different.  The only bad part is that this isn’t really an adventure.  I need a bit more story direction.  The book description has a more direct story than the book itself does.  If you have a good story, then this is an awesome place to play.  If you don’t, then maybe check other adventures.  93%