Daily Punch 4-24-25 Stunner positive quality for Shadowrun 6th Ed

What happened?!

Stunner
Too many blows to the head!
• Cost: 8 Karma
• Game Effect: When you make a melee attack, you may spend 1 edge. If you do, the target must make a Willpower check with the DC equal to the net successes on the attack. If the target fails, the target loses its next major action.

Thoughts?

Daily Punch Tinnitus spell for Shadowrun 6th Ed

WHAT?!

Tinnitus
RANGE TYPE DURATION DV Damage
LOS M S 3 P,,Special
Sonic Boom
RANGE TYPE DURATION DV Damage
LOS (A) P S 4 P, Special
Sound punches your enemies! Sound smashes into the targets. Roll Sorcery + Magic vs. Willpower + Logic. In addition to the damage, the target gains the deafened II condition.. This spell deals sonic type damage.
Sonic Boom has the same effect except it affects all targets in an area.

Thoughts?