I love The Shadow over Innsmouth, so let’s have some of those men and women join the call without knowing it!
The Look (Minor or Major)
You have family that came from someplace that was “off”. The other men and women fighting gave you a wide birth when you joined up or were called. They would fight alongside you, but you’ve always been “off” yourself. this wouldn’t be bad, but you’ve felt the call of something else for a long time, and it’s getting worse.
At a minor level, The Look Hindrance means your character gains 1.5 times as much Dementia, rounded down, and adds +2 to each Horror and Terror effect rolled. In addition you gain a +1 to swim checks. At a major level, your character gains 2 times as much dementia and adds +4 to each Horror and Terror effect rolled. IN addition you gain a +2 to swim checks. If your sanity die is ever reduced to 0, you change into fish monster and turn on your party as you finally succumb to the call you’ve always experienced.