Ring Side Report: RPG Review of The Isle of Sin

Product– The Isle of Sin

System– Pirate Borg

Producer– Dragon Peak Publishing

Price– $2.99 here: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/489303/the-isle-of-sin-pirate-borg?affiliate_id=658618

TL; DR– A fun place to play, but pack your own story.  93%

Basics: Are you worthy of the flame?  The Isle of Sin is a location adventure where the players are caught up in a cult’s antics.  What will you do when you meet the Burned man?

Mechanics or Crunch:  This has solid mechanics.  The monsters are a good fit, and the problems the players face fit well within Pirate Borg’s crunch.  5/5

Theme or Fluff– I like what’s here, but I’m just not sure why I’m here.  The Isle of Sin is fun with phobias, random charts, and well-crafted enemies.  But this really isn’t a one-shot adventure- it’s a one-shot location.  I need a bit more story to guide my players and me.    4/5

Execution: Pirate Borg has a solid community, and this work is on par with the best.  It has a good layout, nice art, and clear guidance that makes it easy for players to navigate.  The price and craftsmanship are exactly what I expect for this one.  5/5

Summary: Pirate Borg has amazing settings.  This book is no different.  The only bad part is that this isn’t really an adventure.  I need a bit more story direction.  The book description has a more direct story than the book itself does.  If you have a good story, then this is an awesome place to play.  If you don’t, then maybe check other adventures.  93%

Leave a Reply